India’s historic victory in the Cape Town Test has momentarily silenced the critics, but questions around Rohit Sharma’s captaincy are still simmering after a string of recent Test defeats. Former Indian cricketer Sanjay Manjrekar, known for his forthright opinions, has reignited the debate by highlighting tactical errors he believes cost India the opening two Tests against South Africa.
Manjrekar, writing in The Times of India, stated, “While celebrating this incredible comeback, we shouldn’t shy away from addressing the captaincy lapses that contributed to our earlier losses. Rohit, despite his batting prowess, has made questionable decisions in both Tests and the preceding ODI series.”
The 55-year-old Rahit Sharma pointed to specific instances, claiming India’s bowling changes in the first Test were “baffling.” He questioned the underutilization of Mohammed Shami and the persistence of Ishant Sharma despite his lack of rhythm. “South Africa exploited the gaps in our bowling attack, and Rohit’s reluctance to adapt cost us dearly,” Manjrekar asserted.
The second Test saw another tactical blunder, according to Manjrekar. He criticized the decision to bat first on a green wicket, handing South Africa the advantage. “India’s top order thrives on chasing, and playing into the hosts’ hands was a strategic miscalculation,” he stated.
Manjrekar further questioned Rohit’s field placements and captaincy during crucial moments. He cited missed DRS reviews and questionable bowling changes that allowed South Africa to build partnerships. “While individual brilliance ultimately won us the Cape Town Test, Rohit’s leadership needs introspection to build long-term Test success,” he emphasized.
Shastri also pointed out the challenges of captaining across formats, claiming it requires adaptability and quick decision-making. “Rohit’s recent success in white-ball cricket shouldn’t be overshadowed by a few Test losses. He’s learning, and the Cape Town win is a testament to his leadership potential,” he added.
The debate over Rohit’s captaincy is likely to continue, especially with a crucial home series against Australia looming. While his batting remains unquestioned, his tactical acumen and ability to guide a young bowling attack will be under intense scrutiny. The upcoming matches will be a litmus test for Rohit’s leadership, and his performance could shape the narrative of his captaincy for years to come.
